
An Open Letter on the Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa Controversy by Pastor Mark Mohr.
I recently had a small spot removed from my face. The biopsy revealed basal cell carcinoma, and the doctors had to cut much deeper and wider than expected to remove the cancer. Today I’m left with stitches, a bandage and a permanent scar. My face has been changed, and in some ways will never be quite the same.
And that’s exactly how I feel about a church I dearly love: Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa.
Just as Mark Hamill’s appearance became noticeably different between Star Wars and The Empire Strikes Back following his facial injuries, I fear that with each passing year and each new change, Chuck Smith’s original vision for Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa is becoming increasingly disfigured and unrecognizable. The name is the same, but the face of the ministry is changing.
When I started Christafari, I attended Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa every Monday night, sitting on the floor in the front row, listening to Chuck Smith and Greg Laurie faithfully preach the Gospel.
We wouldn’t share the Gospel at every Christafari concert today if we hadn’t heard it preached so faithfully back then.
Calvary Chapel shaped my ministry, theology, and understanding of Scripture. Its commitment to verse-by-verse teaching, the gifts of the Holy Spirit without sensationalism, biblical qualifications for pastoral leadership, the Gospel, prophecy, Israel, and the imminent return of Christ resonated deeply with me.
And as a hippie myself, I loved that Chuck Smith didn’t simply welcome the hippies. He loved them enough to preach the truth, confront sin, and introduce them to Jesus.
We affectionately called Costa Mesa “the mothership.”
Today, after ministering in 92 nations and all 50 states, Calvary Chapel is still among the first churches we contact wherever Christafari travels.
But something has changed aboard the mothership.
Since Chuck Smith’s passing, I’ve watched with growing concern as Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa, the birthplace of this movement, has drifted from the convictions that once defined it. Meanwhile, many churches born out of that ministry have faithfully stayed the course. Yet, in response to Costa Mesa’s changing direction, statements, and decisions, a growing number of these churches (including the one many of us currently attend) have dropped the Calvary Chapel name to distance themselves from the very church that started it all.
I’m not suggesting that everyone involved has abandoned the Gospel. But I believe some important theological and ministerial distinctives are being removed, leaving something increasingly unrecognizable.
One thing I’ve always loved about Calvary Chapel is its consistency. It’s like ordering a Big Mac anywhere in the world. Certain ingredients make it unmistakable. Remove enough of them, and you’re selling something entirely different under the same name. I fear that’s exactly what has happened to the mothership.
Recently, my friend Pastor Ken Graves of Calvary Chapel Bangor, Maine, publicly announced that he was changing his church’s name in response to the direction Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa has taken. His announcement garnered considerable attention. But after hearing from numerous fellow Calvary Chapel pastors, he reconsidered and decided to keep the name.
I can only imagine what those conversations sounded like: “Why should we change our names when we’re the ones staying the course? Shouldn’t the church departing from those convictions be the one to change its name?”
And I believe Ken was onto something.
Perhaps God really is calling for a name change. But what if Ken heard the right message and simply applied it to the wrong church?
Why should 1,800 Calvary Chapel churches that remain committed to Chuck Smith’s original convictions surrender the name?
Why shouldn’t the church departing from those distinctives consider changing its name instead?
That brings me to an idea.
Remember the television series Jericho? When CBS canceled it in 2007, fans protested by mailing peanuts to the network. More than 40,000 pounds arrived, and CBS reversed course, bringing the show back for a second season!
Sometimes a simple, creative grassroots movement gets people’s attention.
SO HERE’S MY PROPOSAL: LET’S SEND COSTA MESA A NAME TAG!
If you share my concerns, consider mailing Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa a simple letter with one of those familiar adhesive name tags attached.
On the name tag, write something like:
“HELLO, MY NEW NAME IS…”
“Anything But Calvary Chapel”
“Insert New Church Name Here”
“Time for a New Name”
Inside, if you want feel free to respectfully explain why you believe the Calvary Chapel name should remain associated with the biblical convictions Chuck Smith championed.
And here’s another thought.
Include a dollar.
Not as an insult, but as an expression of goodwill. A small contribution toward the cost of adopting a new name, should the church decide to do so.
Clearly explain that your gift is a restricted donation that must be used exclusively toward the church’s name change or the marketing, publicity, and promotion of its new name. If Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa is unwilling to accept and honor those restrictions, the donation must be returned to the sender. Make sure to include your return address on the outside of the envelope.
Imagine 1,000 letters arriving. Or 10,000!
Would the leadership hear the message?
This isn’t about attacking people. It’s about protecting a legacy that has impacted countless lives, including mine.
Chuck Smith wasn’t simply building a church. God used him to launch a movement that reached hippies, surfers, outcasts, and generations of people hungry for the unfiltered Word of God.
I was one of those people.
And I believe that legacy is worth preserving.
Jesus taught us to love our enemies, pray for those who mistreat us, and go the extra mile. So let’s approach this with conviction, generosity, respect, and prayer.
No insults. No threats. No personal attacks.
Just thousands of believers lovingly asking one simple question:
If you’ve changed the ingredients, shouldn’t you change the name?
My prayer is that Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa would return to the convictions that made it the mothership in the first place.
But if its leadership believes God is taking it in a different direction, perhaps it’s time to give that direction a different name.
Let’s honor Chuck Smith’s legacy, preserve the distinctives of Calvary Chapel, and keep the main thing the main thing.
After all, shouldn’t the name Calvary Chapel still mean something?